“We are new to Agile and are looking to adopt a tool for managing the process... which tool would you recommend?”
There are variations on this question (replace Agile with Scrum/XP/Kanban/whatever, or replace “managing the process” with requirements/development/testing) or maybe its put as “Does TFS work with Scrum?” or “Is Target Process the right tool for XP?” but its the same basic question.
Anyway, I try not to take the bait on these but last week I couldn’t resist and answered it. My answer solicited a positive response from several people so I thought I’d share my answer with more of you and expand on it a little:
For anyone new to Agile (all flavours, Scrum, XP, etc.) I strongly advise avoiding all software tools for managing the process until you get the hang of working in the new manner manually. You will have a faster and more fulfilling learning experience if you do it by hand - pens, cards and white board - for a few weeks before you look at a tool.
There are several dangers with tools:
- You may mistake the tool for the process: e.g. using Rally doesn’t make you Agile
- The tool might not work quite the way you need to work: in your company the tool might not do something you need to do
- The tool might be too strict: when your learning you need a bit of slack
- People may communicate through the tool rather than face-to-face
- You may spend time customizing the tool when you should be focusing on the actual work
- And, when you find things don't work quite the way you want them to it is much easier to change a card or a board than change the software.
Once you have a tool the tool easily becomes an impediment to further change:
- To change you need to change the tool
- You need time to reconfigure the tool (if you can)
- You need time to move your data to another tool (if you can)
- You need to justify the change of tool to those who paid for it: “We paid $10,000 for these licenses 6 months ago, what do you mean you aren’t using it any more?”
- You need to justify spending money on another tool: “And you want me to spend another $5,000 on another tool? Will you use it this time?”
- And you have invested yourself in the tool, you don’t want to admit you got it “wrong”.
Yes I know there are genuine reasons people want to use a tool to help with their work. But choosing the tool before you change is putting the cart before the horse. In my opinion people and teams which spend time evaluating and deciding on their tool are resisting change.
Damn the torpedos just do it!
Do it by hand to start with, give it about 3 months like then then look at some free tools, don't waste time on customizing anything. Give it another 3 months then you should have the experience to find the best tool for your team.
Don’t be scared to change tools - and don’t invest so much in one tool that you can’t change in a few months when you realise its not right.
I’m not saying “Don’t use tools”. To be honest my preference is not to use them, stick to paper, pens and boards. However, I recognise that on some occasions they can help (remote working springs to mind.) But, before you start using one be clear what you need to get from it.
The thing is: Agile is about learning, and you have a much better learning experience when you are manually managing the tasks. If you need a tool to manage them you probably have an over complicated process. When you insert a tool between you and the process you loose sight of what is happening. The tool is a box labelled “magic happens here” and complexity can set in.
There is a story. Its about Jack Kilby - not heard of him? You should have done, he was co-inventor of the Silicon chip. A few years after inventing the chip he helped Texas Instruments develop the calculator. But he regretted the passing of the slide rule.
He said: the slide rule gave engineers the numbers but they needed their intuition to know were the decimal point went. Was the answer 123,456,78 or 123.45678? The calculator took that away and he thought that made for poorer engineering.
Using an tool to manage your Agile process is like that. It removes part of your intuition, part of your understanding.